Tower of Babble Podcast

  • Blog
  • Listen
    • Tower of Babble
    • Game of Thrones
    • Westworld
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog
    • Tower of Babble
    • Game of Thrones
    • Westworld
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Contact

Blog

When not recording their podcast, the Tower of Babble Crew put pen to paper and put down their thoughts and opinions on some of the latest shows, movies and games for the ToB Blog.

  • All
  • Comics
  • Games
  • Misc
  • Movies
  • Podcast
  • TV
Star Wars Battlefront 2 - 1.jpg

Exploring the Frustrations Surrounding Star Wars Battlefront II

Julian Meush November 16, 2017

Update: On the eve of Battlefront II's release, EA announced that they were temporarily pulling all microtransactions from the game. A move like this, so close to release, is unprecedented. It's seemingly a big win for gamers everywhere. However, I could caution people from getting to high on this "victory". Reports suggest that Disney CEO, Bob Iger, called EA and told them to "fix it" as they were concerned that negative aura surrounding the game was damaging the Star Wars brand. So, yes, the microtransaction were removed, for now, but it appears that it wasn't because of fan outcry. Therefor I stand by the piece below as it was originally written.


Star Wars Battlefront II launches to the general public tomorrow and unless you’ve been living under a rock you’ve probably heard about the microtransaction controversy surrounding the game. Essentially EA has implemented a cockamame scheme trying to squeeze every last penny out of Star Wars fans. Without getting into the nitty gritty details, basically what EA has done is implement a “pay to win” system into the core of the game's multiplayer. What makes it worse is that it’s not as straightforward as buying the best weapon to get an advantage. No sir, it’s much more insidious. Instead you pay real money to purchase “loot crates”; a random grab-bag of assorted perks and bonuses. I don’t want to wade into the murky waters of whether these sorts of systems are in fact considered gambling but I will say it definitely feels exploitative and gamers aren’t taking any of this lying down. 

The thing is, there are countless ways to implement microtransactions, but they are always a tradeoff. Some worse than others. Even the previous Battlefront game used a more traditional method of offering periodical DLC packs with new heroes and maps. This meant that with every subsequent DLC pack you splintered the community. This time, in an effort to keep the community together they announced that every DLC pack would be free. They just conveniently forgot to mention that instead they’d be handicapping the actual experience. EA has seemingly chosen to take the lowest hanging fruit by forcing players to spend money if they want to remain competitive. Instead of trying to implement a more equitable solution they have chosen to allow the game's multiplayer to, by all accounts, devolve into a vicious circle of have and havenots. Those who spend money have an advantage, making those who don’t feel like the only way to get ahead is to spend money until they run into the person who spent even MORE money than them and so on. All the while leaving the players who can’t or won’t hand over more cash left in the lurch.

What’s worse is that EA is selling Battlefront II (BF2) at a premium price of $60 US but it’s ALSO using a predatory loot box strategy that is commonly found primarily in free-to-play mobile games. It’s the gaming industry's version of “double dipping”. Gamers are upset and rightfully so. It seems like there’s a new gaming controversy every other week and most of the time it’s nothing more than the gaming community making a mountain out of a molehill, but this time the ire is justified. This has been bubbling under the surface for some time now and it seems like it’s come to a head with BF2. 

So what’s happening here? First and foremost, people feel like they are being ripped off, but I think there’s a lot more to it than that. There’s also a frustration in helplessly watching the gaming industry as it marches in lockstep with capitalism and seemingly ignores the creative and artistic aspects. I know, for me, it’s painful to see an industry full of people who work hard to make amazing game experiences have their work poisoned by a corporate desire to drive revenue. But what can you do about it? Well your choices are extremely limited, and to make matters worse it’s not clear what message you are even sending depending on your choice. On one hand you can choose to not buy the game at all but then you turn around and see that EA continues to announce record revenues. Who are you really hurting with this choice other than yourself? EA apparently doesn’t miss your purchase. They can make it up on the backend with their microtransactions. It’s amazing how much money a kid with access to their parents’ credit card can spend. So instead you say to yourself “fine, I’ll buy the game but I refuse to spend another penny on it”. A noble choice, but again you’re really only hurting yourself as you struggle against other players who willfully handed over the cash for an advantage. EA might notice that, but they probably don’t care.

Star Wars Battlefront 2 - 3.jpg

Again though, what CAN you do? Well you can raise a stink online, and that is clearly been happening. After early estimates of needing over 45,000 hours of play or $2,100 to unlock everything in the game the community came alive and EA backed down some. They lowered the cost of hereos by three quarters while at the same time questioning, but never denying, those original numbers. A small victory I suppose. Unfortunately for many consumers this is their only recourse and things will likely only get more heated as this situation continues. Just look at the recent Reddit AMA (Ask Me Anything) held by a handful of EA developers just the other day. Gamers receiving stock answers for legitimate gripes, which led to the most down voted post in Reddit history. Gamers are frustrated and when they perceive that their complaints are falling on deaf ears it only stokes the flames.

The need to monetize every last piece of gaming has become somewhat of an existential crises for the gaming industry as a whole. There’s no easy answer. Unfortunately I feel my cynicism growing every time this sort of thing happens. It feels especially potent this time though. After being excited about this game for years only to have the launch mired in monetization muck, I’m left feeling helpless and at the mercy of a company essentially holding the Star Wars license hostage. The same company that recently closed down an entire studio that had been working on a game simply because what they were making wasn’t conducive to microtransactions. The same company that as soon as they bought the exclusive rights the NFL saw their Madden games languish in mediocrity once they had no competition to push them. Why should I have any faith that this same company will come to realize they are actually harming the same industry in which they operate? They seemed to have completely lost touch with what gamers actually want and have instead leaned into morally hazy methods of squeezing every last dollar from their “fans”. Sure, gaming is a business, but that doesn’t mean we should sacrifice everything that makes games great in the name of the almighty dollar.

InGames TagsStar Wars, Battlefront II, EA, microtransactions, Loot Boxes, Star Wars Battlefront, Star Wars Battlefront II, Battlefront
  • Blog
  • Older
  • Newer
Subscribe

Support the Show

Become a Patron!


REcent Episodes

Featured
Game of Thrones S2E5 "Ghost of Harrenhal": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 19, 2019
Game of Thrones S2E5 "Ghost of Harrenhal": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 19, 2019

King Renly’s campaign comes to an end, Dany mingles with the Qartheen nobility, The Night’s Watch reaches an ancient stronghold, Cersei withhold’s valuable information, Stannis absorbs the remnants of his brother’s army, Arya serves at Twin’s war council, Tyrion visits the Alchemist’s Guild, Xaro demonstrates his ambition, Jon embarks on a covert mission, and Arya whispers her first name to the God of Death.

Read More →
Feb 19, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E4 "Garden of Bones": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 12, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E4 "Garden of Bones": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 12, 2019

Robb wins another surprise victory but Sansa pays the price, Tyrion offers Joffrey a belated nameday gift, Littlefinger arrives at Renly’s camp with the Lannister’s terms, Daenerys travels to Qarth, Arya is brought to Harrenhal and quickly adds new names to her list, Talisa chastises the King in the North, Catelyn is reunited with Ned, Tywin chooses a new cupbearer, the Baratheon brothers meet one final time, and Xaro Xoan Daxos invokes Sumai… whatever that is.

Read More →
Feb 12, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E3 "What is Dead May Never Die": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 5, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E3 "What is Dead May Never Die": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Feb 5, 2019

Picking up immediately following last week’s cliffhanger, Episode three maintains the slow-burn and deep character work that make Game of Thrones so endearing.

Craster evicts the Night’s Watch, Catelyn meets the full chivalry of the South, Tyrion conspires to forge a new alliance, Brienne earns her place in Renly’s Kingsguard, Cersei torments Sansa over dinner, Balon reveals his war plans, Varys poses an iconic riddle, Arya loses another mentor, and Theon… Theon is just the worst.

Read More →
Feb 5, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E2 "The Night Lands": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Jan 29, 2019
Game Of Thrones S2E2 "The Night Lands": ToB Breakdown Rewatch
Jan 29, 2019

Its week two in the ToB rewatch series, Julian and Dan are back to breakdown Season 2 Episode 2: “The Night Lands”. While the season is still building momentum this episode focused mostly on some much appreciated character development… mixed with a bunch of naked people.

Yoren defends Gendry from the Gold Cloaks, Varys makes his presence known, Sam tries to save Gilly, Rakharo returns to the Khalasar, Craster gives the gods their due, Arya reveals herself to a friend, Theon receives a rude awakening, Janos Slynt is duly rewarded for his service, and Westeros’ two newest kings draw up their battle plans.

Read More →
Jan 29, 2019
Donate

  • Tower of Babble
    King Renly’s campaign comes to an end, Dany mingles with the Qartheen nobility, The Night’s Watch reaches an ancien… https://t.co/Ngb83txwJe
    about 2 hours ago
  • Tower of Babble
    Game of Thrones S2E5 "Ghost of Harrenhal": ToB Breakdown Rewatch https://t.co/oCJwt21iVU
    about 2 hours ago
  • Tower of Babble
    We're recording our #GameofThrones S2E5 today and our #Oscars preview show tomorrow. Big weekend for the ToB Podcast! :D
    about 2 days ago
facebooktwitteryoutubeinstagram
  • Contact

Tower of Babble Podcast

We're a podcast network talking about the things you care about. Characters, places and events that aren't real... but are. Three friends chat about the goings on in geek news. Film and television are the focus with a variety of shows that also concentrate on gaming and comics.

, Winnipeg, Canada

facebooktwitteryoutubeinstagram
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License. Google+